Teter was one of the most versatile athletes in school history, gaining All-America status in both soccer and basketball. In soccer, she was a three-time CAC Player of the Year and second team All-American in 1994 and ranks in the top ten all-time in scoring in program history with 101 career points on 34 goals and 33 assists. In basketball, she was a two-time All-CAC selection and gained honorable mention All-America honors in 1996. At the time of her graduation, she held four season and career records, and scored 1,017 points in her basketball career, becoming one of just three players at the time in Division III history to surpass both 1,000 career points and 600 assists. She led the nation in assists her senior season.